James Houston
— Himself - Host
Randall Balmer
— Himself - Professor of Religious Studies, Barnard College
James Barnwell
— Himself - Pastor (as Rev. James Barnwell)
Greg Flint
— Himself - First Congregational Church (as Pastor Greg Flint)
Morley Hegstrom
— Herself - Principal, Roosevelt Middle School
Ebony Johnson
— Herself - Prevention Outreach Worker
Shelagh Johnson
— Herself - Cascade AIDS Project
Evert Ketting
— Himself - Professor of Sociology
Bristol Palin
— Herself - Teen Pregnancy Ambassador (archive footage)
Deborah Roffman
— Herself - Sexuality & Family Life Educator (as Debbie Roffman)