Luke Wilson
— Charlie Thurber
Gretchen Mol
— Elaine Grasso
David Koechner
— Jay Hadley
Sasha Alexander
— Margaret
Bob Gunton
— William Thurber
Rosemarie DeWitt
— Beth
Michael Cudlitz
— Tim
Andy Daly
— Warren
Ellen Tobie
— Professor Hannah Slocumb
Zach Selwyn
— Buck
Hilary Pingle
— Robin
Lily Holleman
— Blair
Robert Farrior
— Dave Bundy
Nina Hodoruk
— PBS Telethon Host
Atif Lanier
— Whales Basketball Player
William Bogert
— Dean Leakey
Jeffrey Mowery
— Business Schlump