Joe Berg
— Illinois King of Creams
Brooke Guthrie
— Grace Gumble
Connor Kline
— Greg
Nick Rowe
— Chester Swertzwelder
Ryan Jahn
— Junior
Allen Mungo
— Allen Mungo
Jonny Shenk
— Mr Milk
Collin Taylor
— Buddy Boyce
Dave Rich
— Funny Al
Spencer Lamb
— Eddie Jazz
Jeff Morton
— Zeke
Ella Hageman
— Ivette
Gavin Borchers
— Cone Specialist
Josh Philips
— Pizza Delivery Boy
Sydney Malatesta
— Allen's Manager
Will Hattrich
— Beach Dude
Katie Dietrick
— Roxie
Aaron J. Gould
Kellyn Tuttle
— Shelly
Oliver Cox
Griffin Gould
Grant McHugh
— Cream Gossip Reporter