Amy Adams
— Susan
Pierre Agostino
— Father Gabriel
Jeff Bankert
— Mike
Ian Bannen
— Father Matthew
Bob Bouchard
— Villain
John Boyd
— Villain
Charon Butler
— Gloria
Todd Conner
— Virgil
Jon Freda
— Alex Hayes
Kirk Green
— Young Father Matthew
Cecil Hawkins
— Sheriff
Elise Hirby
— Marie Hayes
Gary Kerr
— Ed Hayes
Kevin Kirton
— Villain
Suzanne Law
— Rachel
Jason M. Lefkowitz
— Paul
Deanna Lund
— Helena
Mario Millo
— Villain
Christopher Peacock
— Ken
Michele Peacock
— Carol Hayes (as Michele Vanucchi)
Stewart Penn
— Bus Driver
Richard Powell
— Policeman
Fred Price
— Villain
Nancie Sanderson
— Simona