Thomas Beckwith
— Bishop John Henry Hopkins
Eden Cahill
Hannah Cieto
— Hattie Camp
Emma Kathryn Coleman
— Laura Fay
Lindsey Conter
— Hannah
Jenny Cook
Nise Davies
— Amy Fay (Adult)
Daniel Ely
— Charles Fay
George Ely
— Fred Camp
John Wesley Ely
— Will Camp
Andrew Gilbert
— Frederick Hopkins
Emily Gilbert
— Katherine Fay
Jesse Gilbert
— Choir
Joseph J. Graber
— Dr. Charles Fay
Peter Graber
William Wilberforce Graber
— Lily Fay (Baby)
Brandt Graves
— Thomas
Michael Guli
— Mr. Camp
Sharon Guli
— Mrs. Camp
Sidonia Gustafson
— Amy Fay
Madison Harriet
— Extra
David Jamiel
— Mr. Bradley
Christine Krueger
— Melusina Hopkins
Rowan Lamson
— Ed
Amos Raber
— Uncle Henry (John Henry Hopkins Jr)
Michael W. Smith
— Charles Fay (Adult)
Rebecca St. James
— Mrs. Lewis
Alena Stevens
— Zina Fay
Adeline Tappen
— Melusina Camp
Alina Weber
— Mrs. Delvina