Kenney Myers
— Pastor Luke
Taryn Hacker
— Maggie O'Shea
Jon Hacker
— Jessie McNeil
Shelby Putlak
— Lydia Potter
Mike Rob
— Jimmy Capernaum
Colette Prainito
— Josi
Owen Dammacco
— Tim
Taytem Thomas
— Laudine
Al Pagano
— Joe McNeil
Allison Mullaney
— Abigail (as Allison Mulaney)
Robert Levey II
— David
Catherine Cain
— Martha
Brooke Capuano
— Rachael
Anthony Pallino
— John Potter
Kerry Mannix
— Simone
Alexandra Sepulveda
— Agnes
Gervase Peterson
— Uncle Vic
Justin Scheman
— Mr. Salem
Jennifer Weinberg-Hancox
— Mrs. Salem
London Hancox
— Little Samantha
Cara Maria Sorbello
— Lucy Horton
Anthony Wilcox
— Mr. Lenord
Melanie Little
— Aunt Rosie
Connor Kopko
— Russ
Cody Calafiore
— Jude
Monika Mannix
— Bethany
Aidan Divernam
— Church Congregant
Liam Lawler
— Church Congregant
Paul Mannix
— Church Congregant
Eric Persons
— Church Congregant