Jessica Lowe
— Erica Greenspan
Harvey Guillén
— Andy
Nicole Byer
— Mikayla
Andrew Lewis Caldwell
— Josh Greenspan
Joey Fatone
— Joey Fatone
Rob Riggle
— Mr. Knight
James Austin Johnson
— Jeremy Fischbein
Kathy Griffin
— Stacy Friendship
Nikki Glaser
— Phoebe Schluss
Nicole Richie
— Lizzie Lennox
Will Arnett
— Shamrock
Ken Marino
— Nikki Evans
Sterling Sulieman
— Ben
Layla Mohammadi
— Candace Nicaragua
Madeleine Guilbot
— Young Erica
Oscar Daniel Reyez
— Young Andy
Kennedi Lynn Butler
— Young Mikayla
Teddy Gatewood
— Young Josh
Jon Gabrus
— Paul Dudley