Matt McGorry
— Grey Malcolm
Eric Tollar
— John Hallston
Fred Young
— Charles Evanston
Jason Perlman
— Tom Rollins
May Calamawy
— Kelly Spencer (as May El Calamawy)
Carsen LaBella
— Alexis Meyers
Meg Cassidy
— Becky
Lucas LaLonde
— Harrison
Andrew Stefiuk
— Sanders
Brandon Dise
— Donald Gregor
Paul D'Amato
— Patrick Mathers
Rafael Bernard
— Baugh
Kerem Bürsin
— Grauss
Tyler Bell
— Harvey
Ryan Reed
— Richard Parker
Hartley Sawyer
— Andrew Kepling
Lily Wagner
— Kepling's Girl
Nathaniel Berends
— Man With Beard