Logan Marshall-Green
— Ted Fullilove
David Duchovny
— Marty Fullilove
Stephanie Beatriz
— Mariana
Pamela Adlon
— Blauner
Jason Beghe
— Tango Sam
Daphne Rubin-Vega
— Eva
Evan Handler
— Benny
Santo Fazio
— Shticker
Johary Ramos
— Raul
Ralph Rodriguez
— Hector
Marcos A. Gonzalez
— Umpire
Kathiamarice Lopez
— Young Eva
Liam Garten
— Young Ted
Benny Mora
— Young Marty