Jess Weixler
— Jillian
Jesse Eisenberg
— Tex
Jason Ritter
— Wally
Halley Feiffer
— Nancy
Keir O'Donnell
— Danny
Jocelin Donahue
— Paula
Whitney Able
— Dana
Matt Walsh
— Mr. Hightower
Craig Gellis
— Steel
Suzy Nakamura
— Neighbor
Jordan Davis
— Peter
Tippi Hedren
— Betty
Jennifer June Ross
— Penny
Madison Leisle
— Anna
Joseph McKelheer
— Richard Swinger
Choice Skinner
— Larry
Joe Nuñez
— Yani Perez
John Rosenfeld
— Joe
Angel Parker
— Joel's Mother
Jeff Sloniker
— Harvy
Abigail McFarlane
— Patricia
Taylor Vale
— Twin Bobby
Tanner Vale
— Twin Robby