Meredith Thomas
— Sheriff Hudson
Jill Awbrey
— The Woman
Gigi Gustin
— Tammy Wright (segment "Nite Flirt")
Bill Moseley
— The Caller (segment "Nite Flirt")
Sheila Ball
— Myra Wright (segment "Nite Flirt")
Stephon Strickland
— Ray (segment "You Promised")
Moriah N. Boone
— Carol (segment "You Promised")
Jenna Kanell
— Lila Cameron (segment "Miniature")
Philip Estrin
— Winston
Joseph "Jojo" Martinez
— The Boy (segment "We All Scream")
Amber Medina
— The Mom (segment "We All Scream")
Mr. Sweetie
— Himself (segment "We All Scream")
Peter Xifo
— Janitor (segment "Miniature")
Amber Pauline
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Karma Rx
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Dan Swaney
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Or Mussman
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Jeff Kongs
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Nicholas Adams
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Collin Carter
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Nick Meyer
— Toy (segment "Miniature")
Matthew Hersh
— Officer Mooney (segment "You Promised")
Nick Nicholson
— Jim (segment "You Promised")
Justin Miles
— Will (segment "You Promised")
Jessie Allen Hitner
— Rob (segment "You Promised")
Allison Victoria-Wolfe
— Officer Scully (segment "You Promised")
Tara Price
— Officer Starling (segment "You Promised")