Ethel Merman
— Annie Oakley
Bruce Yarnell
— Frank Butler
Rufus Smith
— Buffalo Bill Cody
Jerry Orbach
— Charles Davenport
Benay Venuta
— Dolly Tate
Harry Bellaver
— Sitting Bull
Jack Dabdoub
— Pawnee Bill
Wayne Hunter
— Tommy Keller
Tony Catanzaro
— Wild Horse
Ronnie Carroll
— Foster Wilson
Jeanne Tanzy
— Jessie Oakley