Doris Day
— Aimee Alexander
Ronald Reagan
— Grover Cleveland Alexander
Frank Lovejoy
— Rogers Hornsby
Eve Miller
— Margaret Killefer
James Millican
— Bill Killefer
Russ Tamblyn
— Willie Alexander
Gordon Jones
— George Glasheen
Hugh Sanders
— Joe McCarthy
Frank Ferguson
— Sam Arrants
Dorothy Adams
— Ma Alexander
Bob Lemon
— Jesse 'Pop' Haines
Jerry Priddy
— Ballplayer
Peanuts Lowery
— Ballplayer
George Metkovich
— Ballplayer
Irving Noren
— Ballplayer
Hank Sauer
— Ballplayer
Al Zarilla
— Ballplayer
Gene Mauch
— Ballplayer
Walter Baldwin
— Pa Alexander (uncredited)
Jack Carr
— Angry Fan (uncredited)