Basil Hoffman
— Wilbert Moser
Daniel Roebuck
— Hitch
Stephanie Zimbalist
— Pastor Mimi
Madelyn Dundon
— Alex
Duane Whitaker
— Payton
Willard E. Pugh
— Pete
Timothy E. Goodwin
— Barney
Patrick Voss Davis
— Lincoln
Marsha Dietlein
— Beth
Angelo Maldonado Jr.
— Huey
Kathy Patterson
— Sarah Finn (2020)
Valynn Turkovich
— Sister Alice
Donnamarie Davis
— Church Parishioner/Sightseer
Hal Miers
— Young Arthur
Dave Alspach
— Roger
Nick Bialis
— Louie
Lance August
— Detective Clay
Tamara Hayes
— Cafe Patron
Carol Thorpe
— Church Parishioner/Sightseer
John Reshetar
— Young John Wolfe
EV Dundon
— Miriam (1972)
R.J. Koker
— Plumber William
Wilhelmenia Ford
— Kathy Reade (2020)
Chris Naples
— Dewey
Grant Hershman
— Young Officer
Nathan Szydlow
— Young Bob Fleck
Samantha Patten
— Self
Mick Trombley
— Mr. Dunham