Gabe Dobson
— Agent Sebastian Moore
Zack LaChance
— Frankie "The Boss" Russoti
Danny Huot
— Tommy "The Tooth" Palahniuk
Cable Jacques
— Carmine "The Jokester" Zamperini
Jon Dube
— Lou "The Exaggerated Hand Gesture" Hoffman
Ethan Richards
— Steve "No Relation" Corleone
Braden Foley
— Dougie "The Plot Device" Margolis
Ellie Mason
— Chief Karen Sterns
Maddie Vaughan
— Agent Walsh
George Horvat
— Agent Williams
Delaney Ziegman
— Elder Lorton
Gaia Ayres
— Elder Lane
Anna Bruner
— Elder Broderick
Lauren Mesley
— Valerie Higgins
Erin Gray
— Gloria
Lindsay Armstrong
— Edwige