Nancy Stafford
— Alma Watkins
Jesse Kove
— Clay Cassidy
Lev Cameron
— Luke Watkins
Livi Birch
— Adele Watkins
Bailey Chase
— Hunter Braddock
A Martinez
— Abraham
David Gridley
— Deputy Fisher
William Shockley
— Deputy Jensen Longley
Drew Waters
— Butch Broussard
Tom Proctor
— Deacon Kane
Erin O'Brien
— Willa Broussard
Gary Wheeler
— Judge Thorne
Daniel Williams-Lopez
— Joaquin Vasquez
Amanda Righetti
— Lily Rayne
Bruce Boxleitner
— Ben Watkins
Martin Kove
— Ambrose Masse
Chris Mulkey
— Sheriff King
Travis Elliston
— Cavalry Soldier
Jeremy Gauna
— Chaska
Abigail Haley
— Dakota
Craig Hensley
— Captain W H Brown
Robert Jensen
— Drover #1
Jamie Kornacki
— Townsperson
Don Most
— Chester Tilly
Constantino Nuzzo
— Cavalry 2
John Scott
— Townsperson
Kellen Tanner
— Townsperson