Should've Been Romeo

Paul Ben-Victor

— Joey

Ed Asner

— Charlie

Jordenn Thompson

— Billie

Carol Kane

— Ruth

Michael Rapaport

— Danny

Kelly Osbourne

— Nicole

Howard Rosenman

— Henry

Renée Taylor

— Tillie

Natasha Henstridge

Mary McCormack

— Ellen

Tina Majorino

— Alice

Costas Mandylor

— Mason

Vincent Ventresca

— Matt

Christian J. Meoli

— Eddie

B.J. Britt

— T.J.

Sam Hale

— James

Theo Alexander

— Milton

Eric André

— Buzz

Garrett Brawith

— Pickle

Alexandra Choi

— Party Goer

Charlene Clark

— Party Goer

Josh Cowdery

— Jaffe

Emi Eliza

— Dippette

Alan Gray

— Artist on Bus

Evan Handler

— Stewart

Nichole Hiltz

— Anna

Steve Hytner

— Rick

Kim Kendall

— Julie

Elizabeth Ann Koshak

— Talent Agent

Art Kulik

— Party Guy