Sam Bevill
— Sam
Summer Thorson
— Summer
Brandon O'Grady
— Cupid
Celeste Bird
— Celeste
Roxanne Chevalier
— Roxanne
Quinn Chambers
— Quinn
Sarine Krovitz
— Sarine
Jake Marone
— Jake
Sheffield Hocker
— Sheffield
Brandon Thorson
— Crackerjack
Matthew Levine
— Sheffield's friend
Ethan Pearl
— Sheffield's friend
Dillon Thorson
— Jake's friend
Garrett Grande
— Cupid's assistant
Grace Kelly
— Grace
Jackson Harn
— Jake's friend
George Bladon
— guy who went to the wrong party
Ethan Cianflone
— Uber driver
Jennifer Grande
— Roxanne's Mom
Cody Grande
— Cody