Nonnas

Vince Vaughn

— Joe Scaravella

Lorraine Bracco

— Roberta

Talia Shire

— Teresa

Susan Sarandon

— Gia

Linda Cardellini

— Olivia

Brenda Vaccaro

— Antonella

Drea De Matteo

— Stella

Joe Manganiello

— Bruno

Campbell Scott

— Edward Durant

Richie Moriarty

— Dan McClane

Geoffrey Owens

— Phil

Will Fitz

— Italian Partygoer

Craig 'Radio Man' Castaldo

— Bum

Quincy Dunn-Baker

— Vito

Kate Eastman

— Maria

Tom Johnson

— Vendor

Jimmy Smagula

— Mr. Pionconne

Tammy Pescatelli

— Cousin Tammy

Jamie Eddy

— Gabriella

Maureen Mountcastle

— Older Gabriella

Dana de Celis

— Dana

Karen Giordano

— Nonna

Robert John Gallagher

— The cousin from Philly

Marcos A. Gonzalez

— The Priest

Jack Casey

— Young Bruno

Victor Kozlowski

Liz Weinstein

— Chair Yoga Instructor

Theodore Helm

— Young Joe

Adam Ferrara

— Arthur Romano

Dee Roscioli

— Young Roberta