Lily Rabe
— Mona Peek
Daniel London
— Elevator Man
H. Jon Benjamin
— Police Officer
Kevin Corrigan
— Hector Freegood
David Cross
— Timmy (voice)
Jane Lynch
— Honey Strumpet
Eugene Mirman
— Night Elevator Man
Xander Berkeley
— Dad
Richard Cox
— Stalker Timmy
Ann Dowd
— Honey Woman
Jon Glaser
— Tooot
Sakina Jaffrey
— Lacticia Utt
Mary Kay Place
— Mom
John Sayles
— Cramden
Marian Seldes
— Eunice (voice)
Eli Wallach
— Maestro
Sean Mana
— Wilson Utt