Lucy Hale
— Eva Vaugh
Jedidiah Goodacre
— Kyle
Virginia Gardner
— Kelly
RJ Fetherstonhaugh
— Jake
Brooke Nevin
— Valerie
Brendan Morgan
— Mitch
Samer Salem
— Norman
Bethany Brown
— Robin
JayR Tinaco
— Anthony
Edem Nyamadi
— Brad
Laura Yenga
— Winnie
Pete MacLeod
— Finance Scam Date
Kyle Mosonyi
— Daddy Dom
Jessimae Peluso
— Molly
Sequoia Wiseman
— Tara
Threnody Tsai
— Lila
Shaughnessy O'Brien
— Kayla
Jon Gabrus
— Jon
Cam Woodman
— Guitar Guy
Nina M. Fillis
— Improv Actor
Haley Victoria Hunt
— Hunt Sheryl
Brad Abramenko
— Man 1
Kendra Hesketh
— Server
Justin Lacey
— Randy
Spencer Borgeson
— Jogger
Zan Klein
— Cop
Wayne Corbeil
— Townsfolk (uncredited)