Jingle Smells

Ben Davies

— Nick Gutman

John Schneider

— Dusty Gutman

Eric Roberts

— Marty Grevell

Jim Breuer

— Blake Ashton

Brad Stine

— Michael Perkins

Dylan Postl

— Popfrog

Victoria Jackson

— @EnchantressKale

Jaclyn Stapp

— Julie Vincent

James Storm

— Mason Stone

Logan Sekulow

— Douglas Firlong

Diane Sargent

— Lisa

Tyson Jones

— Silas

Maurice Greene

— Wilson

Katherine Scarlett

— Silas' Mom

James Arnold Taylor

— Big Shot Hollywood Agent

Ketrick "Jazz" Copeland

— Dickel

Michael Kavalus

— Finn Franklin

Anna Sekulow

— Ashley Weaver

Bart Scott

— Troubadour

Mike Huckabee

— Apostle Polly (voice)

Sean Hannity

— Self

Jay Sekulow

— Self

John Schlitt

— Self

Jordan Sekulow

— Mr. Mayor

Crystal Mayes

— Protester and Prisoner (uncredited)