Come to the Stable

Loretta Young

— Sister Margaret

Celeste Holm

— Sister Scholastica

Hugh Marlowe

— Robert Masen

Elsa Lanchester

— Amelia Potts

Thomas Gomez

— Luigi Rossi

Dorothy Patrick

— Kitty

Basil Ruysdael

— The Bishop

Dooley Wilson

— Anthony James

Regis Toomey

— Monsignor Talbot

Mike Mazurki

— Sam

Walter Baldwin

— Claude Jarman (uncredited)

Pati Behrs

— Nun (uncredited)

John Bleifer

— Rosey (uncredited)

Nan Boardman

— Nun (uncredited)

Wally Brown

— Howard Sheldon (uncredited)

Russ Clark

— Policeman (uncredited)

Louise Colombet

— Nun (uncredited)

Teddy Driver

— Cherub (uncredited)

Robert Foulk

— New York City Policeman (uncredited)

Gordon Gebert

— Willie Matthews (uncredited)

Eula Guy

— Mrs. O'Connor (uncredited)

Louis Jean Heydt

— Al Newman (uncredited)

Tim Huntley

— Buzz Townsend-Cooper (uncredited)

Danny Jackson

— George (Jarman's Assistant) (uncredited)

Virginia Keiley

— Mrs. Townsend-Cooper (uncredited)

Nolan Leary

— Bethlehem Station Master (uncredited)

Henri Letondal

— Father Barraud (uncredited)

Ian MacDonald

— Mr. Matthews (uncredited)

Marion Martin

— Rossi's Manicurist (uncredited)

Edwin Max

— Whitey (uncredited)