Jonah Feingold
— Leo Kadner
Sarah Coffey
— Eva Shapiro
Jackie Sandler
— Susan
Caroline Aaron
— Lila
Lori Tan Chinn
— Jaya
Judy Gold
— Rabbi Zelden
Catherine Cohen
— Pizza Influencer
Larry Owens
— Producer
Noa Fisher
— Jensie
Seth Barrish
— Mark
Kuhoo Verma
— Samantha
Djouliet Amara
— Molly
Hannah Pilkes
— Isabel Cohen
Jared Freid
— Greg
Megan Bitchell
— Christmas Girl
Dale Moss
— Christmas Kyle
Talia Suskauer
— Millie
Joey Dardano
— Luca
Derrick Delgado
— James
Zoe Isabella Hoffmann
— Sally
Antoinette LaVecchia
— Silvia
Lauren Servideo
— Maria