Christopher Eccleston
— James
Bella Thorne
— Bella
Dylan Baker
— Cop Brandon
Linus Roache
— The Pastor
Isabella Astbury
— The Christian Girl
Tammy Blanchard
— Tonia
Gideon Glick
— Blake
Colin Bates
— Raymond
Jordan Alexander
— Savannah
Giles Surridge
— John Gates
Brandon McEwan
— Teen Justin
Leni Zieglmeier
— Teen Savannah
Dylan McEwan
— Teen Jason
Tom Pecinka
— Chris
Clayton Nemrow
— Bill Parks
Jason Parks
— Jason
Cali Albanese
— Rachael
Josh Priday
— Teen Jonathan
Oliver Johns
— Little Justin
Harry Johns
— Little Jason