Nathan Ballard
— Darren Mellema
Sofia Moreno
— Sophia Mellema
Faysal Lawrence
— Chaz
Noah Alderete
— Chuy
Isabel Klein
— Lauren
Matthew Jehle
— Caterpillar
Josh Burns
— Documentary Serial Killer
Stephanie Schulz
— Documentary Interviewee
William Jerry
— Fake Mr. God Victim
Cameron Richter
— Mr. God
Jacqueline Diaz
— No Cash Girl
Zoey Green
— Balloon Girl
Scott Green
— Foreman