Jackie Tohn
— Nomi
Sarah Podemski
— Mara
Aya Cash
— Rabbi Rachel
Seth Green
— Daniel
Judah Lewis
— Jonah
Nina Bloomgarden
— Lindsey
Jake Ryan
— Westpot
Thani Brant
— Tal
Jim Kaplan
— Tums
Bekah Zornosa
— Dahlia #1
Steve Guttenberg
— Manny
Jillian Jordyn
— Dahlia #2
Jacob Moskovitz
— One-Nut
Ben Krieger
— Evan
Maxwell Friedman
— Matt
Jill Kargman
— Deb
Jonathan Silverman
— Eli
Dan Ahdoot
— Stan
William DeMeritt
— Jeff
Allegra Leguizamo
— Abby
Bern Cohen
— The Mashgiach
Max Samuels
— Yoni
Shira Averbuch
— Bekka
Aviya Leong
— Lily
Maud Arnold
— Adi
Sage Spielman
— Barak Thespian