Charlie Korman
— Noam
Michael Zapesotsky
— Jonah
Katherine Kamhi
— Michelle
Liz Richman
— Miriam
Victor Kallett
— Zach
Jenna Herz
— Tali
Danny Chon
— Kyle
Ayelette Robinson
— Mrs. Fleischman
Jill Karrenbrock
— Rebecca
David Pevsner
— Ari
Rita Zohar
— Mrs. Helfgott
Robert Paden
— Meyer
Steve Sobel
— Rabbi Gross
Avra Friedman
— Deena
Kai Logan Fishman
— Lev
Ariana Perlson
— Rachel
Max Mattern
— Eitan
Catherine Bruhier
— Mary, the Librarian
Brennan Cattalini
— Daniel
David Eugene Sweat
— Church Member
Lauren Alison Wargin
— Family Member
Mary Cavaliere
— Nurse
Donovan Tyrone Woods
— Choir Leader