RJ Mitte
— Fitz
Finn Wittrock
— Tom Bell
Ritchie Coster
— Film Chair
Tovah Feldshuh
— Mrs. Lucas
Jake Weary
— Dickie
Dan Lauria
— Mr. Romney
Amy Forsyth
— Avery
Sam Strike
— Jay
Joy Suprano
— Nicole
Luke Slattery
— Movie Tom
Chris Gray
— Movie Dickie
Eric Striffler
— Stage Manager
Samantha Yestrebsky
— Assistant