Tom Blyth
— Lucas
Russell Tovey
— Andrew
Amy Forsyth
— Emily
Maria Dizzia
— Marie
Christian Cooke
— Ron
Gabe Fazio
— Uncle Paul
John Bedford Lloyd
— Lt. Sollars
Sam Asa Brownstein
— Christian
Darius Fraser
— Jeff
Alessandra Ford Balazs
— Jessie
Joseph Emmi
— Gus
Luke Burke
— Ben
Marlene Mancini
— Nonna
Henry Stockwell
— Man in Bathroom #1
Ben Anderson
— Man in Bathroom #2
Jason Ngo
— Man in Bathroom #3
Charli Emmi
Oliver Fedrizzi
Emily Fedrizzi
— Lucas's Cousin
Carmen Emmi III
— Lucas's Cousin
Joseph Emmi Jr.
— Toddler Lucas
Rachael Haegerty
— Lucas's Cousin
Christine Albright
— Aunt Trish
Lauren Stanton
— Joanne
Babs Rubenstein
— Theater Attendant
Colby Cote
— Andrew Double
Oliver Bradford
— Andrew's Son