Eric Roberts
— Judge Martin Joy
Mena Suvari
— Leah Grievess
Cathy Moriarty
— Grandma Judy
Frankie Faison
— Arthur Yearwood
John Savage
— Edward Clayborn
Eliza Roberts
— Grace Stuart
Christopher Egan
— Peter Grievess
Bill Barrett
— Samuel Grievess
Magnus Diehl
— Samuel Grievess (teen)
Wyatt Solis
— Samuel Grievess (young)
Amanda Clayton
— Tristan Grievess
Morgan Harvill
— Tristan Grievess (teen)
Alissa Marie Pearson
— Tristan Grievess (young)
Jayce Bartok
— Teddy
Hunter Nance
— Teddy (teen)
Smith Gilbert
— Teddy (young)
Kevin Interdonato
— Dr. Burns
Franky G
— Phoenix
Holly Zuelle
— Jackie Yearwood
Landon Moss
— Kenny
Jann Ellis
— Althea
Sean Fosse
— Prosecuting Attorney