Peter Coyote
— Narrator (voice)
Anne Nelson
— Self
William J. Barber II
— Self
Steve Schmidt
— Self
Elizabeth Neumann
— Self
Randall Balmer
— Self
Lisa Sharon Harper
— Self
Russell Moore
— Self
Jonathan Wilson-Hartgrove
— Self
Katherine Stewart
— Self
Linda Gordon
— Self
Eboo Patel
— Self
Ken Peters
— Self
Samuel Perry
— Self
Jim Wallis
— Self
Brent Allpress
— Self
John Marty
— Self
Strom Thurmond
— Self (archive footage)
Jim Jordan
— Self (archive footage)
Mallory McMorrow
— Self (archive footage)