Preston J. Arrow-Weed
— Narrator (voice) / Joe Homer
Maria Amorocho
— Maria Montielo
Russell Fega
— Lt. Cave Couts
Stuart Proud Eagle Grant
— Lt. Thomas Sweeney
Earl Smith
— James Ohio Pattie
Sam Smiley
— George Johnson
Cindy Reed
— Olive Oatman
Don Defina
— Father Kino
Carlo Michael Mancini
— Captain Alarcon
Bill Pakinkas
— Mr. Oatman
Bobbie Burtler
— Mrs. Oatman
Faron Owl
— Santiago
Francisco Lerma
— Juan Bautista de Anza
Philbrick Emerson
— Salvador Palma
James Hill
— Abel Lincoln
Stacy Sant
— Young Olive
Roddy Escalante
— Runner / Apache
Sean Schuett
— Lorenzo Oatman
Pam Novak
— Pearl Heart