Courtne Alyssa Moran
— Lindsey McCabe
Kevin Sorbo
— Rev. Ernestine Coughlin
Dean Cain
— Judge Franks
Michael Sigler
— Steve McCabe
Tim Wilkins
— Coach Jimmy
Elbert Kim
— Brian Compton
Jana Lee Hamblin
— Janet Peters
Victor Cordova
— Pastor Tim Campbell
Tim Perez-Ross
— Caleb Stowe
Thomas C. Stuhr
— Sports & Kinesiology Expert
Ronald Regar
— Alex (as Trey Regar)
Katherine Elise Shaw
— Principal Tanner (as Katherine Shaw)
Gretchen Trasorras
— Donna (ticket lady)
Jason Jeske
— Gary (Lawyer #1)
Matt Hamner
— Lawyer #2
Larry Orton
— School Attorney
Logan Seese
— Bailiff
Terry Hamner
— Courtroom Police Officer
Felicia Andes
— Courtroom Reporter
Chelsea Queen
— Swim Meet Judge
Dan Argiro
— Dr. Dan
Jessica Adams
— Dr. Sara
Aaron Drabnis
— Dr. Sam (Trans)
Marra Johnson
— Bri
Dan Cunliffe II
— Expert 1 (Dad)
Kirk Ayers
— Expert
Frankie Kovar
— Expert
Keith Rose
— Expert
Pamala Kennedy
— Expert (Teacher)
Isabella Sanchez
— Expert (Young Female Athlete)