Evelyn Giovine
— Verity/Chastity
Damon Dayoub
— Pastor Dean Humphries
Samuel Larsen
— Gage
Raquel Davies
— Ruby
Judy Kain
— Louanne
Greg Finley
— Sam
Stefanie Estes
— Heidi
Phuong Kubacki
— Kayla
Wes Martinez
— Jose
Daniel Link
— Detective Peter Frederick
Pamela Fields
— Judith
Zia Graca
— Security Guard Amir
Brit Laree
— Rachel
Amanda Melby
— Coroner
J. Roppolo Jacobs
— Monica Whitman
Abe Ruthless
— Drunk Guy John
Tasha Dixon
— Taqueria Owner
Alex Kass
— Finance Bro
Isabella DeVlaeminck
— Chapel Band (Drums)
Jacob Letman
— VIP Congregant
AD Warfaa
— Smoking Man
Dan Weisgerber
— Congregation member