Tori Kamal
— Alan Carpenter
Jamie Zin
— Satan / Pete / Landlord
Matthew J. Lindblom
— Beelzebub Scratch
Jillian Elaine
— Candice
Tyler W. Moore
— Gary / Additional Voices
Jemma Bayley
— Bonnie
Monica Honey
— God
David J. Cantu
— God / Additional Voices
Melissa White
— Elizabeth Lanchester
Elijah Muldrow
— Jesus
Ace Dionne
— Carla
Carl G. Brooks
— Richard
David Wayne Young
— Nick
Caitlyn Cody
— Lisa
Molly Strickler
— Additional Voices
Lily Nordstrom
— Sunny
Christopher Strong
— Additional Voices