Michael Maher
— Old John
Jon Rizzo
— John
Aiden Bauer
— Young John
Nathan Cantrell
— Jesus
Matt Richardson
— Satan
Valerie Bracken-Dykes
— Mary Mother of Jesus
JD Chambers
— Lazarus
Lauren Daniel
— Mary of Bethany
Caleb Abraham
— Philip
Andre Bauer
— Octavius
Levi De Valle
— Andrew
Timon Emch
— Young Jesus
Stephanie Evans
— Martha
Noah Hart
— Young Lazarus
Vida Casper
— Young Mary of Bethany
Brandon Lautzenheiser
— James
Nathan Middleton
— Father Zebedee
Nick Perry
— Riktor
Jamy VanSyckle
— Nathaniel
Deb Wilson
— Mother Zebedee
Isabelle VanSyckle
— Young Martha