Sam Nivola
— Jeremy
Sophie Telegadis
— Evie
Mohana Krishnan
— Aparna
Aidan Laprete
— Yoshi
Molly Shannon
Kumail Nanjiani
— Mr. Rivers
Lilah Pate
— Samantha
Bri Giger
— Officer Lee
Alyssa Milano
Kevin Iannucci
— Justin
Marley Aliah
— Lo
Clayton Farris
— Fur Salesman
Ella Stiller
— Dakota
Chelcie Lynn
Robert Walker Branchaud
— Coach Custer
Travis Przybylski
— Paul
Thomas S. Beck
— Tophat
Brennen Suttle
— Frat Party Director
Finn Harry
— Scooby
Casey Murray
— College Student