Lexi Leigh
— Little Bo-Peep (segment: "Li'l Blow Peep")
Candy Apples
— Cat (segment: "Hey Diddle Diddle")
Nikki Scott
— Peter's Wife (segment: "Peter Peter Pumpkin Fucker")
Tricia Devereaux
— Little Red Riding Hood (segment: "Little Red Riding Hood")
Dave Hardman
— Big Bad Wolf (segment: "Little Red Riding Hood") / Sheep (segment: "Li'l Blow Peep")
Billy Glide
— Moon (segment: "Hey Diddle Diddle")
Ron Jeremy
— Cow (segment: "Hey Diddle Diddle")
Buck Adams
— Peter Peter Pumpkin Eater (segment: "Peter Peter Pumpkin Fucker")
The Woodsman
— The Woodsman (segment: "Peter Peter Pumpkin Fucker")