Tom Lipinski
— Dom McGuire
Adelaide Clemens
— Deb Catalano
Tammy Blanchard
— Melissa
Giancarlo Esposito
— Father Heery
Kristen Connolly
— Betsy
Will Rogers
— Kevin
Valerie Harper
— Kathryn
Bobby Moynihan
— Roddy
Robert Arensen
— Physical therapist patient
Jo Armeniox
— Christine
John Auer
— Acting Student
Jackie Brown
— Parishioner
Thomas Brucia
— Barbershopper #2
John Cariani
— Odd Interviewer
JR Carter
— Parishioner
Rob Yang
— Fred
Paloma Guzmán
— Jennifer
Larry Clarke
— Mike
Maria Dizzia
— Serious Lady
Loudon Wainwright III
— Tom
Stephanie Sherry
— Acting Student
Kate Reinders
— Mary
Kerry O'Malley
— Theresa
Kianné Muschett
— Eager Lady
Thomas Middleditch
— Game Guy
Brendan O'Malley
— Chad
Frank Harts
— Khakis
David Dantowitz
— Barbershopper #1
Hal Cohen
— Barbershopper #3
Dominic Colón
— Hefty Dude