Della Reese
— Elsie Waybright
Teri Polo
— Melinda Mead
Kevin Sorbo
— Nathan Davis
Tamera Mowry-Housley
— Daphney Conroy
Lisa Arnold
— Mrs. Bell
Bradley Dorsey
— Steve Dalt
Tyler Humphrey
— Lucas Conroy
Jaiden Kaine
— Jeb Conroy
Toby Nichols
— Bully / Classmate
Izabela Vidovic
— Olivia Mead
Rob Boltin
— Mr. Brennan
Dylan DePaula
— Classmate
Natalie Hultman
— Becca Holloway
Brock Patrick Kaufman
— Joey Becker
William J. Wells
— Orphan Ricky Sanchez (as William Wells)