Theo Rossi
— Bryan Bruton
Aya Cash
— Sienna Bruton
Tammy Blanchard
— Maura Willis
Tony Hale
— Kai
Ronnie Gene Blevins
— Vern
Kayden Brenna Tokarski
— Older Crystal
Aaron Quick Nelson
— Duncan
Kelvin Hodge
— Jamal
Alexandria Arnold
— Younger Crystal
Dana Namerode
— Elana Porter
Daniel Rivera
— Repo
Clayton LaDue
— Gary
Ryan Francis
— Mac
Phebe Cox
— Vero
Alex Farnham
— Evan
Tommy Nash
— The Brother
Jesse O'Neill
— The Boyfriend
Julie Toche
— The Girlfriend
Michele Ilese Decker
— Grandma Franny
Davina Reid
— Elana's Mom
David Docobo
— Richie
Daniel Chase Waters
— Uncle Bob
Jordan Salloum
— Hendry C.O.
Josh Kelling
— Gainesville Deputy
Britton Webb
— Officer Nash
Ann Mahoney
— Assistant Debbie
Douglas Dean Mitchell
— RMC Warden
Clipper Hackett
— New RMC Warden
Juliana Folk
— Head of FDLE
Emily Sanchez
— Head of Classification