Johnny Whitaker
— Michael
Fred Gwynne
— Patience, the Guardian Angel
Cab Calloway
— Gabriel
E.G. Marshall
— God
John McGiver
— Angel of the Peace
Tony Randall
— Democritus
George Rose
— The Celestial Psychopomp
Connie Stevens
— The Flying Mistress
James Coco
— Father
Evelyn Russell
— Mother
Cris Alexander
— Raphael
George Blackwell
— The Coach Driver
Mary Jo Catlett
— The Scribe I
Lu Leonard
— The Scribe II