Tina Fey
— Portia Nathan
Ann Harada
— Mrs. Lafont
Ben Levin
— Junior Lafont
Dan Levy
— James
Maggie Keenan-Bolger
— Girl on Tour
Gloria Reuben
— Corinne
Paul Rudd
— John Pressman
Wallace Shawn
— Clarence
Elaine Kussack
— Abby
Christopher Evan Welch
— Brandt
Michael Genadry
— Ben
Juliet Brett
— Praying Applicant
John Brodsky
— Smug Kid
Camille Branton
— Gymnast
Sarita Choudhury
— Rachael
Michael Sheen
— Mark
Ken Barnett
— Admissions Counselor
Nat Wolff
— Jeremiah
Travis Bratten
— Quest Student
Tanisha Long
— Quest Student
Nadia Alexander
— Quest Student
Karen Pham
— Quest Student
Travaris Spears
— Nelson
Lily Tomlin
— Susannah
Rob Campbell
— Richard
Sonya Walger
— Helen
Olek Krupa
— Polokov
Roby Sobieski
— Makeout Guy
Lauren Schaffel
— Student at Party
Brian Charles Johnson
— Student at Party