Kevin Arnold
— Perry 'Pears' Matthews
Olivia Schaperjohn
— Tiffany
Jillian Weinzapfel
— Jessica Archer
Jeremy Brailsford
— Hollis Archer
Leo Kempf
— Sly
Joe Gilpatrick
— Ritchie
Jakob Bilinski
— Derek DeGarmo
Emily Durchholz
— Sarah Hightower
Kevin Roach
— Eddie Hightower
Alice Shen
— Simone
Jeffrey Dumond
— Frank Guthridge
Shahzaib Raza
— PhoneGuy
LilyBea Ireland
— Heartbreaker
Takeyah Barnhill
— Angela Guthridge
Bruce Womback
— Grandpa Tom
Deborah Lee Hall
— Parking-Lot Karen
Alyssa Rhoads
— Yoga Instructor
Lily McCurdy
— Tiffany's Friend #1
Gennie Adams
— Tiffany's Friend #2
Crystal Mullen
— Tiffany's Friend #3
Nathan Veazey
— Mr. Meyers
Kurt McWilliams
— Mr. Meyer's Boyfriend
Chelsea Sowder
— Comic Book Store Patron
Marci McCurdy
— Karen's Grandbaby
Lincoln McCurdy
— Karen's Grandbaby