Matthew Sharpe
— Adam Benson
Whitney Richardson
— Nicole Bensen
Russell Sage Patrick
— Russ Thompson
Brax Holloway
— Charlie O'Connor
Sonia Debreczeni
— Alaina Fiore
Tony Wood
— Corey Solis
Amy Insley
— Detective Alex Booth
Chaz Riddle
— Detective Ralph Victor
Laura O'Neal
— Ethel Sanders
Pamela Mann
— Faye Jackson
Katina Householder
— Basketball Neighbor /Barbecue Guest /Investigation Onlooker
Michael Householder
— Basketball Neighbor
Randy Crocker
— Distracted Driver
Robert Kyle Jr.
— Barbecue Neighbor
David Moore
— Barbecue Guest /Newspaper Neighbor
Jillian Sigler
— Barbecue Guest
Maverick Householder
— Barbecue Guest
Gabby Crocker
— Barbecue Guest
Lori Moulton
— Barbecue Guest 6 /Investigation Onlooker
Stephen Neal
— Dog Walker
Lucrecia Rodriguez
— Dog Walker
Jack Roy
— Jack walking Dog
Guy Ailam
— Neighborhood Jogger
Tylan Nance
— Homeowner Watering Tree
Mandy Rivera
— Neighbor at Mailbox
Wendy Mungal
— Neighbor at Mailbox
Mathew Dodge
— Investigation Onlooker /Live Streamer
Jackie Lucia
— Goth Neighbor
Jd Roberts
— Jason Reed