Hank Greenspan
— Ethan Bloomfield
Joshua Malina
— Gary Bloomfield
Caroline Valencia
— Camille
Carlos Ponce
— Father Diaz
Rachelle Lefèvre
— Rabbi Dani
Mindy Sterling
— Elaine
Jessica Galinas
— Rachel Bloomfield
Jude Friedman
— Mason
Laurel Levey
— Hilda
Kamilo Alonzo
— Kid Student
Jesse Aponte
— Teacher
Mariana Arevalo
— Party Guest
Willy Bearden
— Family Member
Renata Bresciani
— Secretary
Robert DeAngelo
— Bar Mitzvah Guest
Kinley Kingcade
— Kid Student
Stefano Kruger
— Church Parishioner
Alexandra Astor
— Bar Mitzvah Guest
Callie Herren
— Allie