Pete Gardner
— Bucky Bantershire
Marissa Jaret Winokur
— Sweet Tooth
Ryder Robinson
— Teddy Pinston
Lilah Collins
— Polly Pinston
Lori Nasso
— Mrs. Pinston
Gracie Moore
— The Smile Judge
Paul Wong
— The Smile Panelist
Sarah DeVincentis
— Ginger
Sasha Ivanir
— Margot
Isaac Amsterdam
— Warren
Jesse Gillingham
— Dinah (Smile Contestant)