David Pevsner
— Ebenezer Scrooge
Tim Kazurinsky
— Jacob Marley's Ghost
Rusty Schwimmer
— Freda
Bruce Vilanch
— Fezziwig
Megan Cavanagh
— Terry / Ghost of Christmas Present
Richard Ganoung
— Colin
David Shae
— Bob Cratchit
Ronnie Kroell
— Randy / Ghost of Christmas Past
Drew Anderson
— Young Ebenezer Scrooge
Nicholas Bailey
— Young Jacob Marley
Christopher Allen
— Bill
JoJo Baby
— Ghost of Christmas Future / Spectres / Delivery Person
P.J. Powers
— Wraith
Scott Duff
— Drew
Amy Matheny
— Mary
Fawzia Mirza
— Marshall
Peter Mohawk
— Kyle
Michael Joseph Mitchell
— Scrooge's Father
Becca Kaufman
— Becca
Richard Knight Jr.
— Dick
Tom Downing
— Brent
Allison Torem
— Franny
Liam Jones
— Tiny Tim
Dixon Kaufman
— Cassie
Delaney Kaufman
— Ruby
Elijah Pendleton
— Rafael
Keante Pendleton
— Simon
Michael Termine
— Pawn Shop Owner
Judith Light
— Narrator (voice)