Evender Hodges Sanders
— Elise
Suzanne Jennings
— Megan Redmond (Present)
Ian Scott
— Dennis Redmond/David
Kenny Bristow
— Raymond Mortimer
Caleb Paschall
— Lionel Williams
Alexis Ward
— Nurse
Chip Sebastian
— Sheriff Blackburn
Bernadette West-Fugate
— Mrs. McNeal
Andrew Farmer
— Mason
Danielle Coyne
— Katherine Rucker
Tamara Villalon
— Jane Mortimer
Carly Wheeler
— June Redmond
Olivia Sanders
— Lizzie Redmond
Daryn Russell
— Megan Redmond
Dennis Dillon
— Radio
Wes Gift
— Search Party #1
Kevin Minor
— Search Party #2
Chris Langford
— Search Party #3
Hunter Groves
— Search Party #4
Traviss Whitt
— Real Dennis
Chelsea Witt
— Real June
Richard Mills Allen
— Search Party #5
Ka'ssee Rhe'anne
— Real Megan
Natilee Wells
— Real Lizzie
Matthew Smith
— Search Party #6
Matthew Higdon
— Real Ripper
Dakota Fish
— Search Party #7
Brian Tucker
— Search Party #8
Willie Madden
— Search Party #9
Tianna Redford
— Sarah McNeal